Teams 
| Year | All-Stars (Pos.) |
|---|---|
| 2009 | Adrian Gonzalez (1B), Heath Bell (P) |
| 2008 | Adrian Gonzalez (1B) |
| 2007 | Trevor Hoffman (P), Jake Peavy (P), Chris Young (P) |
| 2006 | Trevor Hoffman (P) |
| 2005 | Jake Peavy (P) |
| 2004 | Mark Loretta (2B) |
| 2003 | Rondell White (OF) |
| 2002 | Trevor Hoffman (P) |
| 2001 | Tony Gwynn (OF) -- special All-Star guest, Ryan Klesko (1B), Phil Nevin (3B), Bruce Bochy (coach), Todd Hutcheson (trainer) |
| 2000 | Trevor Hoffman (P) |
| 1999 | Tony Gwynn (OF)--injured, dnp, Andy Ashby (P), Trevor Hoffman (P), Bruce Bochy (Manager) |
| 1998 | Tony Gwynn (OF), Kevin Brown (P), Trevor Hoffman (P), Greg Vaughn (OF) |
| 1997 | Tony Gwynn (OF), Ken Caminiti (3B), Steve Finley (OF), Bruce Bochy (coach) |
| 1996 | Tony Gwynn (OF)--injured, dnp, Ken Caminiti (3B) |
| 1995 | Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1994 | Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1993 | Tony Gwynn (OF), Andy Benes (P) |
| 1992 | Tony Gwynn (OF), Benito Santiago (C), Fred McGriff (1B), Tony Fernandez (SS), Gary Sheffield (3B), Bob Day (trainer) |
| 1991 | Benito Santiago (C), Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1990 | Benito Santiago (C)--injured, dnp, Tony Gwynn (OF), Roberto Alomar (2B) |
| 1989 | Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1988 | Mark Davis (P) |
| 1987 | Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1986 | Tony Gwynn (OF) |
| 1985 | Tony Gwynn (OF), Steve Garvey (1B), LaMarr Hoyt (P), Terry Kennedy (C), Graig Nettles (3B), Rich Gossage (P), Garry Templeton (SS), Dick Williams (manager) |
| 1984 | Steve Garvey (1B), Tony Gwynn (OF), Rich Gossage (P), Dick Dent (trainer) |
| 1983 | Dave Dravecky (P), Terry Kennedy (C) |
| 1982 | Ruppert Jones (OF) |
| 1981 | Terry Kennedy (C), Ozzie Smith (SS) |
| 1980 | Dave Winfield (OF) |
| 1979 | Dave Winfield (OF), Gaylord Perry (P) |
| 1978 | Rollie Fingers (P), Dave Winfield (OF) |
| 1977 | Dave Winfield (OF) |
| 1976 | Randy Jones (P), John McNamara (coach) |
| 1975 | Randy Jones (P) |
| 1974 | Johnny Grubb (OF) |
| 1973 | Nate Colbert (1B) |
| 1972 | Nate Colbert (1B) |
| 1971 | Nate Colbert (1B), Preston Gomez (coach) |
| 1970 | Cito Gaston (OF) |
| 1969 | Chris Cannizaro (C) |
